Indianapolis Colts vs Las Vegas Raiders Start ‘Em Sit ‘Em Week 5 2025 Fantasy Football Guide

Indianoplis Colts Jonathan Taylor week 3 confidence picks

The Colts look to roll into this matchup against a struggling Raiders squad and continue building momentum.

Taylor and Jeanty will be a Key Head to Head Matchup

Quick Start/Sit Table

PlayerStart/SitMeter (🔥 Strong Start / ❄️ Sit / 🌙 Sleeper / 💪 Flex)
Jonathan TaylorStart🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Michael Pittman Jr.Start💪💪💪💪
Tyler WarrenStart🔥🔥🔥
Daniel JonesStart🔥🔥🔥
Ashton JeantyFlex💪💪💪
Geno SmithSit❄️❄️
Brock BowersSit❄️❄️
Jakobi MeyersSleeper🌙🌙
Ian Thomas (TE)Sleeper🌙
Carter Runyon (TE)Sleeper🌙🌙

The Skinny

Daniel Jones has erased doubts about his future as Indianapolis’ starter, looking confident and efficient under center. The Raiders, meanwhile, have been inconsistent on offense and could be without key playmakers in the passing game, making them hard to trust in fantasy formats.

This matchup leans heavily toward the Colts, who feature one of the league’s best backs in Jonathan Taylor and reliable offensive pieces like Michael Pittman Jr., rookie TE Tyler Warren, and rising RB Ashton Jeanty. For the Raiders, Jakobi Meyers has separated himself as a steady target-getter, while sleeper tight ends could emerge if injuries linger at the position.

Start ‘Em

🔥 Jonathan Taylor – RB, Colts

Taylor has been everything Indy could ask for this season. The Raiders’ run defense has been shredded repeatedly, and Taylor is the engine of this offense. Expect a heavy workload and big fantasy output.

Projection: 21 carries, 112 yards, 1 TD; 3 receptions, 18 yards

💪 Michael Pittman Jr. – WR, Colts

Pittman remains one of the most underrated possession receivers in the league. His red-zone presence keeps him fantasy relevant every week. He’s a steady WR2/flex option in PPR formats.

Projection: 6 receptions, 73 yards, 1 TD

🔥 Tyler Warren – TE, Colts

The rookie continues to grow into his role, becoming a reliable chain-mover for Jones. The Raiders have struggled against tight ends, making Warren a sneaky solid start.

Projection: 4 receptions, 65 yards, 1 TD

Colts’ rookie TE Tyler Warren has set an NFL record already in prolific start to career – Billy Helen via The Sporting News

🔥 Daniel Jones – QB, Colts

Jones has been sharp, protecting the football while showing chemistry with his playmakers. He’s not an every-week starter yet, but in 12-14 team leagues or for injury fill-ins, he’s proven serviceable with some rushing upside.

Projection: 236 passing yards, 2 TDs; 32 rushing yards

💪 Ashton Jeanty – RB, Colts

ashton jeanty
Aug 16, 2025; Paradise, Nevada, USA; Las Vegas Raiders running back Ashton Jeanty (2) walks off the field after the Raiders were defeated by the San Francisco 49ers 22-19 at Allegiant Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Stephen R. Sylvanie-Imagn Images

Jeanty is finding his footing and could see an increased role as Taylor’s complement. With opposing RBs having success recently against Las Vegas, Jeanty has sneaky RB2/flex appeal.

Projection: 9 carries, 38 yards; 3 receptions, 31 yards, 1 TD

Colts’ Jonathan Taylor Recognizes Ashton Jeanty’s Talent – Drake Wally SI.com

Sit ’Em

❄️ Geno Smith – QB, Raiders

Smith’s play has been wildly inconsistent, with poor decision-making costing drives. Until he shows consistency, he’s better left on benches—even in superflex formats.

Projection: 212 yards, 1 TD, 1 INT

❄️ Brock Bowers – TE, Raiders

Bowers missed Thursday’s practice and has been slowed all year by nagging injuries. Even if active, his usage and effectiveness have dropped. He’s not a trustworthy start.

Projection: 3 receptions, 27 yards

Sleepers

🌙 Jakobi Meyers – WR, Raiders

Meyers has become the most dependable option in the Raiders’ passing attack, outpacing Tre Tucker in both targets and production. In a game where Vegas could be trailing, Meyers offers sneaky flex value.

Projection: 7 receptions, 64 yards

🌙 Ian Thomas – TE, Raiders

If Bowers and Mayer can’t go, Thomas could slide into snaps. He’s more of a desperation TE streamer but could pick up a few dump-offs in garbage time.

Projection: 3 receptions, 22 yards

🌙 Carter Runyon – TE, Raiders

Runyon, the athletic rookie out of Towson 🐯, may get an opportunity if injuries force him onto the field. His athleticism gives him higher upside than Thomas, especially in the red zone.

Wrap Up

The Colts are in control of this matchup from a fantasy perspective. Jonathan Taylor remains a must-start centerpiece, while Pittman, Warren, and Jeanty round out strong supporting options. Daniel Jones is proving to be more than just a streamer, flashing solid fantasy value with improved confidence.

For the Raiders, it’s slim pickings. Jakobi Meyers offers flex value due to target volume, while backup tight ends like Ian Thomas and Carter Runyon are deep-league dart throws if the team’s starters are sidelined. Meanwhile, Geno Smith and Brock Bowers are sits until further notice.

This one looks like a Colts-heavy fantasy matchup, with the Raiders struggling to find reliable contributors outside of Meyers.

More Great Content

Scroll to Top