Buffalo Bills vs Kansas City Chiefs Start Em Sit Em Week 9 2025 Fantasy Football Guide

bills

insert photo of Mahomes and Allen together

Round 12 Mahomes vs Allen

The next installment of Mahomes vs. Allen — Chiefs vs. Bills — could be a preview of the AFC Championship Game. The Bills have dropped two of their last three but come in hungry after a rebound week. Expect fireworks in Arrowhead as two of the league’s top offenses clash again.

🔥 Quick Start/Sit Table

PlayerTeamDesignationOutlook
Josh AllenBills✅ StartDual-threat QB primed for multiple TDs
James CookBills✅ StartShould eclipse 100+ yards and find the end zone
Khalil ShakirBills💪 Flex StartTrending up as a reliable WR3/flex option
Keon ColemanBills🚫 SitStruggling to find rhythm — bench until further notice
Bills DefenseBills🚫 SitAvoid in high-scoring matchup
Patrick MahomesChiefs✅ StartLocked in and spreading the ball efficiently
Rashee RiceChiefs✅ StartHeating up — 80+ yards and a score expected
Travis KelceChiefs✅ StartAlways a must-start — red zone TD likely
Kareem HuntChiefs💪 Flex StartValue rising, especially in PPR formats
Xavier WorthyChiefs💪 Sleeper/Flex7 targets last week — volume play with upside

🦬 Buffalo Bills

Start ‘Em

Josh Allen (QB) – Allen is due for a monster game in primetime. Expect at least one passing and one rushing TD as he goes blow for blow with Mahomes. He thrives in these high-pressure shootouts.

James Cook (RB) – Cook broke out last week with two touchdowns and looks like the focal point of the offense again. The Chiefs’ defense has struggled against backs catching passes — Cook could rack up 100+ yards and a TD.

💪 Khalil Shakir (WR) – We called him a flex last week, and he delivered. Shakir’s chemistry with Allen keeps growing, and he’s emerging as a sneaky midseason PPR gem.

Khalil Shakir Week 9 outlook – Derek Brown via

Sit ‘Em

Keon Coleman (WR) – The rookie has cooled off dramatically. He’s not getting the separation or volume needed to trust him in fantasy lineups right now.

Bills Defense – This matchup always leans toward a shootout. With Mahomes playing sharp football, it’s best to stream another D/ST this week.

🏹  Kansas City Chiefs

Start ‘Em

Patrick Mahomes (QB) – Mahomes is locked in again, utilizing all his receivers and backs effectively. Expect multiple scores and a vintage performance in front of the home crowd.

insert Rice Photo

Rashee Rice (WR) – Rice has bounced back nicely after a quiet stretch. He’s developing as Mahomes’ top option again and should put up 80+ yards and a touchdown.

Bills scouting report: Can the defense shut down Chiefs receiver Rashee Rice? – Lance Lysowski via buffalonews.com

Travis Kelce (TE) – You already know the rule — never bench Kelce. Expect 5–6 grabs and a red zone score.

💪 Kareem Hunt (RB) – A strong waiver wire pickup who’s earning more touches each week. If his involvement in the passing game keeps climbing, he’s a valuable flex play with sneaky upside.

💪 Xavier Worthy (WR) – The rookie is getting consistent looks (7 targets last week). His speed gives him weekly big-play potential — a viable sleeper in deeper leagues.

💥 Final Take:

This game screams fantasy fireworks. Both quarterbacks should deliver QB1 numbers, while skill players like Cook, Rice, and Shakir offer big upside in what could be another instant classic between two AFC powerhouses.

More Great Content

Scroll to Top